Weekly Voice Insight #118 — Let the Snow Fall
I watched dogs interacting with one another, often without their owners constantly calling them back or correcting their behavior. Children, too, seemed to have opportunities to explore without an adult intervening at every turn. Of course, I was only observing brief moments in other people's lives, but the difference caught my attention.
In addition to teaching music at the university level, I also taught a first-year course designed to help incoming students adjust to college life. As part of the course, students wrote reflections about their lives at home and their experiences before coming to college. Reading those reflections, along with observing how they managed the responsibilities of university life, gave me some insight into the different levels of independence they had experienced.
I became familiar with two expressions associated with these experiences: helicopter and snowplow parenting. The first comes from a teenager who described his mother as hovering over him like a helicopter. The second describes parents who attempt to clear obstacles from their children's paths before they encounter them.
Snowplows are a familiar part of winter here in Minnesota, and I find the image particularly descriptive. A snowplow clears the road ahead, removing the obstacles so we can continue without difficulty. Imagine applying that same approach to someone else's life, continually clearing the way before they've had an opportunity to deal with a problem themselves.
My experience teaching voice also taught me something about my approach to correction. I could often hear several things in a student's singing that needed attention. If I heard something that needed improvement, why wouldn't I address it?
I remember one particularly gifted college student who was bright, quick to learn, and accustomed to getting things right the first time. I offered encouragement and positive feedback, but as we continued working, I would hear something else that could be improved and offer another correction. Even though I was addressing these things individually, the experience became increasingly frustrating for the student, to the point of becoming emotional.
I'm a passionate person, and when I recognize someone's potential, I can become quite enthusiastic about helping them develop it. As I gained experience, I began to understand that not everyone received that enthusiasm in the same way. Looking back at that particular student, I can see how each additional correction might have felt like another failure, or even a disappointment to me as their teacher. I had to become more attentive to how students interpreted my feedback, regardless of my intention.
I began paying closer attention to the frequency and intensity of my corrections. I also had to consider how much information a student could reasonably absorb and apply at one time. I had to establish a hierarchy, decide which correction would be most useful, and recognize when to allow the student to continue singing without interruption. By doing so, I could observe whether they recognized and adjusted something on their own or needed further guidance.
When you've spent years developing expertise in a particular field, you can often recognize a problem long before someone with less experience does. You may know exactly what needs to happen next. And because you're responsible for the outcome, the temptation to intervene can be considerable.
But how does someone develop judgment if we continually make those decisions for them?
A manager who constantly checks, corrects, and redirects may unintentionally encourage employees to depend on that intervention. Someone who removes every anticipated obstacle may leave employees with fewer opportunities to develop the experience they'll need when a problem arises without immediate assistance.
This doesn't mean abandoning people to difficulties they aren't prepared to manage. There are circumstances in which intervention is necessary, particularly when safety, serious consequences, or the needs of others are involved.
Peter Drucker, in Managing Oneself, advises us to “listen first, speak last.”
Epictetus offers a related observation:
“Be silent for the most part, or speak only what is necessary, and in few words.”
For those of us who teach, coach, or lead others, it's important to remain aware of when our expertise is needed and when someone else would benefit from the opportunity to use their own.
The breath before offering the next correction, we might consider the following:- What could I learn by listening a little longer?
- What might the other person learn if I gave them the opportunity?
“I begin to speak only when I’m certain what I’ll say isn’t better left unsaid.”
— Cato the Younger
Find the DYAV newsletter, website, blog, reflection journal, and Voice Insights archive below:
#DevelopYourAuthenticVoice #WeeklyVoiceInsights #LetTheSnowFall #LeadershipCommunication #LearningThroughExperience

No comments:
Post a Comment